Looking to sell your used car in Newmarket or anywhere in Ontario? On average, sellers earn 20–40% more than a dealer trade-in — and it’s free to list. Carco handles the marketing, buyer screening, and paperwork for you.
Prefer to talk? Call (647) 985-8520
Car consignment is a service where you authorize Carco to sell your vehicle on your behalf at full retail price. You keep ownership until a buyer is confirmed — then you receive the sale price minus a flat service fee. No strangers at your door. No upfront costs.
Start by filling out our quick consignment form. It only takes 2 minutes.
Leave your car at our secure Newmarket facility, or keep driving it while we market it for you.
We’ll present verified offers. Accept one and get paid same-day. It’s that easy.
We offer flexible payment options to suit your needs. Whether you prefer a certified cheque, direct deposit, or bank draft, we work with you to ensure a smooth and secure transaction.
Securely receive funds straight into your bank account. Most deposits complete within 24 hours after your car is sold.
Prefer a physical payment? We'll issue a certified cheque from a trusted Canadian bank for fast deposit or cashing.
Choose a secure bank draft payment, ideal for sellers who want guaranteed funds with minimal risk.
Receive guaranteed funds via secure wire transfer — ideal for higher-value vehicles or out-of-province sellers.
No delays. No surprises. Carco ensures fast payouts and peace of mind for every seller in Newmarket and across Ontario.
Carco consignment customers share their experience selling cars in Newmarket and across the GTA.
★★★★★ 4.8 · based on 75 Google reviews
Nick L
February 2026
“Customer service was excellent. They followed up appropriately without being pushy. It felt like they genuinely wanted to help rather than just close a sale. Overall, a positive experience. Professional team, fair pricing, and smooth transaction. I would consider working with them again in the future.”
via Google
Yaneska Pernia
January 2026
“Absolutely amazing customer service. Very straightforward, helpful, transparent. They helped me with every single one of my needs, Kuzey went above and beyond to work with my budget and find me the car of my dreams at an amazing cost. I have never had such an easier experience at a dealership. I absolutely recommend them to anyone that is looking for a car and does not want to deal with the headaches and trickery of other dealerships. Thank you guys once again for everything!!”
via Google
Jonathan Perruzza
December 2025
“Kuzey was extremely professional and very friendly. My situation was definitely complicated and he worked with me calmly and diligently to get my dream truck in my driveway. On my end there was many complications along the way and he came up with practical solutions very quickly. I would highly recommend carco for any body looking for there next vehicle no matter what there situation is”
via Google
Ola Omopariola
November 2025
“I recently purchased my car from Carco, and Kuzey made the experience truly unforgettable! From the moment I started talking to Kuzey, he was attentive, knowledgeable, quick response, and genuinely enthusiastic about ensuring the process is perfect. His expertise and passion throughout the process were fantastic. Kuzey took the time to answer all my questions, and his professionalism, kindness, and warm smile made me feel like I was in good hands. He went above and beyond to ensure the car was in order, and I appreciated his dedication to getting the job done right. I'd highly recommend Kuzey and the Carco team to anyone in the market for a new or used vehicle - they won't disappoint! Thanks, Kuzey, for an amazing experience.”
via Google
Robert DiCarlo
November 2025
“I'd like to share my experience with the salesmen at Carco. They are by far the most straightforward car salesmen I have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. Their honest approach to negotiating was fair and insightful. we negotiate with integrity that gives them a very good reputation in my opinion. thank you. it was an easy, smooth stress-free experience for me”
via Google
Carco is based at 3-1124 Stellar Dr, Newmarket, ON — and we work with sellers across the province. Whether you’re in Toronto, Mississauga, Brampton, Hamilton, Barrie, Ottawa, Kingston, London, Windsor, or anywhere in between, we offer convenient vehicle pickup and secure processing. Prefer to drop off? Visit us in Newmarket for priority consignment.
Contact us today to discuss your options or book an appraisal.