Sell My Car in Newmarket, Ontario
Get more for your car with Carco. Consign it for full retail value, trade it in, or take a fair cash offer. It is free to list, and we handle the marketing, buyer screening, and paperwork for you.
Three ways to sell your car in Newmarket
Every seller is different. Whether you want the highest price or the fastest sale, Carco has an option that fits.
Consign for the most money
We list and sell your car at full retail price. You keep ownership until it sells and earn on average 20 to 40% more than a trade-in. This is the best choice if your goal is top dollar.
Learn about consignmentTrade in toward your next car
Buying your next vehicle from Carco? Roll your current car into the deal as a trade-in and keep it simple. Browse our inventory and we will value your trade at the same time.
Browse inventorySell for cash, fast
Need to sell quickly? We can make a fair offer to buy your car outright. It is usually less than consignment nets, but it is the fastest, most hands-off way to sell.
Request an offerWhy sell your car with Carco in Newmarket
Carco is an OMVIC-registered dealership in Newmarket, Ontario, at 3-1124 Stellar Dr. We built our business on transparency, so selling your car with us means no strangers at your door, no lowball haggling, and no guessing what your car is really worth.
We handle the photos, the marketing across multiple platforms, the buyer calls and screening, and all of the paperwork. You stay in control and get paid once your car sells. We serve sellers across Newmarket, Aurora, Richmond Hill, East Gwillimbury, Bradford, King City, and the wider Greater Toronto Area.
Want the full breakdown of how consignment works and how much more you could make? Read our guide on car consignment in Newmarket.
Selling your car in Newmarket: common questions
What is the best way to sell my car in Newmarket?
For most people, consignment gets the most money. Carco lists and sells your car at full retail price and you keep ownership until it sells, earning on average 20 to 40% more than a dealer trade-in. If you prefer speed and simplicity, we can also discuss a trade-in or a direct cash offer.
Does Carco buy cars for cash in Newmarket?
Yes. If you want to sell quickly, we can make a fair offer to purchase your vehicle directly. It is usually less than you would net on consignment, but it is fast and hassle-free. Contact us with your vehicle details and we will let you know your options.
How much does it cost to sell my car with Carco?
There is no upfront cost to consign your car. We charge a flat service fee only when your vehicle sells. If it does not sell, you do not pay anything.
Can I sell my car if I still owe money on it?
Yes. We regularly help sellers with an outstanding loan or lien. We will walk you through the payout and paperwork so the sale is clean and legal.
Do I have to live in Newmarket to sell my car with Carco?
No. Our hub is in Newmarket, but we help sellers across York Region and the GTA, including Aurora, Richmond Hill, East Gwillimbury, and Bradford, with pickup available across Ontario.